We started out the session by taking a moment to review everyone’s stories and talk about how well or poorly they’d worked out. The best assessment of their utility was which ones could be easily remembered vs. which ones had to be looked up. After some discussion, we desired to loosen up the Story structure a little bit. Rather than asking players to outline the whole story, they could fill in a little bit less – the ending and maybe the beginning – and we’d proceed from that.
It makes advancement a bit fuzzier1, but we immediately got grippier stories as the players focused on what they wanted to have happen rather than counting out the right number of steps to fulfill their mechanical obligations. They absolutely retain the right to introduce as many steps into the story as they like, but removing the obligation to do so is absolutely liberating.
I’m going to chew on his approach a little bit more and see if there’s a way to introduce it into the economy of the game. It’s easy to integrate play-wise. It’s effectively player generated milestones with a lot of explicit authority (which rocks) but I feel like it might also hold the key to addressing the spotlight issue, which could arguably be measured by who gets more story beats over time. However, that’s some future thought.
The session itself was almost entirely talky. A little bit of die rolling, but a lot of it was handled dicelessly with skills as permissions2. The trip from Kirkwall to Vendel was uneventful (a fact helped along by the warship that accompanied them most of the way) but Vendel itself was another matter. Things were tense. The docks were stuffed with Eisen ships and the taverns full of Eisen mercenaries. Everyone knew a Thane had declared himself in Kirk, but no one knew what it meant yet, but uncertainty was through the roof.
Doctor Valdis’s Patron, Red, was not at her usual coffee house, but was instead attending a meeting of the League, which the heroes got to observe some of, including some politics among the chairs, and the various voices urging caution versus immediate action. Two key points were revealed – this Thane had the support of an unknown number of Jarls (especially in the North and central parts of the nation) and that specifically he held the mint and most of the productive mines of Vesten3.
During a pause, they spoke with Red, who was surprised to hear about the princesses engagement to the MacDuff, but quickly looked to try to find a way to leverage that information. Discussion of the politics of the situation followed. Red was worried about the mint, but rather more worried about the potential destabilization the host of mercenaries represented4 and the overall lack of information about the situation.
She also asked the heroes to go speak to the new Thane, since they had an existing connection to him. She was worried things were already bad because a thousand mercenaries had been sent north as soon as the new came in, and the situation may have already gone pear shape. The heroes agreed and were provided papers and a fast carriage.
The trip north was fast at first, while the posts were in good shape, but slowed down as they discovered the passing mercenaries had depleted the horse supply. They did encounter a retreating group of mercenaries who Basilio and Zeta recognize as young men from the group of Montaignian expatriates whose church they attend. By their reports, they had joined up with the hastily assembled force, but quickly found it not ot their liking, especially with the Eisen toughs, and they had been walking back for a while. They also warned of Trolls, but no one took that very seriously.
A bit further on they found signs of a battle, but very few graves. Further still was a checkpoint on the road, manned by Vesten in traditional garb. Surprisingly, they did not hassle the heroes, save to ask a few fairly normal questions. Not far past the checkpoint, the heros saw a prison camp which (presumably) held the defeated mercenaries. From that point north, the Posts were in fine order, though the people manning them were a little confused. The new Thane had apparently declared it would be business as usual.
They found their way to Kirk, which we all agreed looked like something out of Skyrim. Of note, there was now a smoking ruin where the Objectionist Cathedral’s construction site had previously stood, but otherwise all was well. Once again, inspection at the gates was businesslike, but the invocation of the Thane’s daughter’s name was sufficient to hurry them along. Meeting the Thane (Karl, played in the movie by Karl Urban, better groomed than the average vested and armed like an Eisen), they delivered letter from hisdaughter and received an invitation to dinner.
Dinner lead to conversation, much of which was a roundabout (and polite) argument between Doctor Valdis (speaking for capitalism) and the Thane (Speaking for the necessity of government), and the Thane ended up getting some support, most concretely because he too was concerned about the mercenaries on Vesten soil, and from his perspective, Vesten had been able to indulge the league because all her neighbors had been paralyzed by internal problems, but that was not a long term strategy. Vesten had to have a leader (and a military), and it had to have it’s wealth spread out further than just Vendel.
A few things came of this and followed:
- As part of the discussion, the Thane revealed that the mines had been using slave labor (since liberated). The heroes were, of course, taken aback, and when Basilio discovered the Mining Chair (who had all been a loud voice for attacking the Thane) was actually a Castillean, he decided that Steps Must Be Taken.
- Captain Quinn had heard that Sir Mandrake had been to Kirk, and the Thane acknowledged that the man was a friend, but had not seen him in some time. His wife, covered up a reaction, but later on she came to Quinn and told him a bit more, including that last she knew, he had headed to Vendel, and she gave him a token that had been Important to Mandrake.
- Valdis consulted with Shuri, the Thane’s sage, about her axe. Shuri was more intereted in her, and opted to take her out for a test of strength, wits and resolve on the icy slopes of the mountain overnight. When they found her the next morning, she had three mortal wounds worth of exposure but had also learned one of the Galdr Runes (Time)
- Zeta identified and stymied a would-be assassin, accidentally killing him with his now poisoned knife. It also revealed the assassin’s partner, the same shadow-wielding figure they had faced in Kirkwall. He made it clear he intended to collect the price on Zeta’s head, and she made id clear how welcome he was to try such a suicidal thing. In the Aftermath, the Thane seemed to recognize the magic in use and asked her if she intended to kill this man. As she said yes, he gave her a black gem which, which grasped, turned into a knife of shadows (hell yeah, 1e callback) . He also gave her a token that any Die Kreutzritter would recognize.
The heroes agreed to take the delivery from the mint (less a meticulously documented amount for back wages for the liberated slaves) down to Vendel as a show of good faith on the Thane’s part, and as the carriage was being loaded, we wrapped for the night.
- And I’m ok with that. If there is one thing there is no lack of in this game, it’s advancement. ↩︎
- That is, if you have a high skill, that is taken into account in how things are described and in what the GM simply says “Yes” too. It’s a technique that every game and GM use to differing extents, but where the knobs are set matter a lot. Specifically, it’s very useful for keeping information flowing smoothly. ↩︎
- A plot hook lifted from Nations of Theah vol. 1, but with 90% fewer slavery apologists. ↩︎
- Remember, Vesten has no standing army or navy to speak of, and Mercenaries – especially ones ho haven’t gotten paid – have a historical habit of calling dibs on whatever’s on hand. This point becomes relevant later in discussion with the Thane. ↩︎
“90% fewer slavery apologists?”
I, er, may have submitted some feedback on this point.
Nations of Theah v1 presents slavery in Vesten as something that everyone knows about and it’s sort of accepted as part of business. Setting aside that it contradicts Pirate Nations, I was really uncomfortable with that in my game (since I’m ok with the league being morally grey, but that was too far), so I kept the core idea, but made it the secret work of a few villainous members of the League (and made it something offensive enough that objection to it got the new Thane critical support).
Vesten’s use of slave labor falls in the same camp as women in Vodacce.
I understand if you don’t feel comfortable with it, but it’s there as something Heroes can change.
It’s also there as something GMs can change. Which Rob did.
Oh totally! I was just kind of confused as to whether Vesten was making apologies for slavery or we were. 🙂
I admit, it is unfair of me to dismiss it merely because it’s dark – there are plenty of dark things in the setting. I’m 100% on board with Sexism in Vodacce, monsters in Eisen, corruption in Montaigne and so on. But in each of those cases, I can point clearly to the sense that this is a *problem* to be pushed against (complete with forces working against these ideas) . Vesten slavery, at least as presented, is institutional – just a fact of life that apparently a lot of people are A-OK with it. One or two NPCs dislike it, and opposition gets vaguely referenced, but if I want to hero it up, I’m largely going to build it from whole cloth.
Which is fine, of course. It’s easily enough done. And I suspect some folk’s Theah’s are improved by Vesten having an open slaving market. But it definitely caught me off guard. 🙂
(Aside: I must also concede: It probably bugs me more because I contrast is with how *magnificently* slavery has handled in Pirate Nations. )
(Oh, yeah, totally Vesten as slavery Apologists, not you guys.)
I’d also like to point out that as of right now, Nations of Theah v1 is in backer preview, which means we’re still in a stage where we’re actively taking feedback about the book’s content and can course correct it in response to audience concerns.
I really hadn’t meant to make more than a passing comment. 🙂
I know what you meant. But I also know how the Internet responds to “passing comments” on the blogs of visible industry personages, so I figured that providing the additional context was worth doing. Better safe than sorry, you know?
Also, it’s not the final text. Changes have been made since you saw it last. 🙂
I am super regretting that WordPress does not allow me to +1 comments.
Urgh. The Vesten.
This is pretty much my only major gripe with the new Theah. I was pretty hyped to see them, only to have them remain nearly unchanged from their 1st Edition version.
To be a country of 9th Century hicks with a few modern city is grating on me.
Iron Age Vikings. Goddamn Vikings. Bleh.
I’m going to be writing a new Expy-Scandinavia if I’m starting a campaign there.
Otherwise, I’m loving these recaps. It’s an amazing insight into how people are wrangling the system.